0001625: complements of collections with unset attributes - XMMS2

Mantis Bugtracker

Viewing Issue Simple Details [ Jump to Notes ]

[ View Advanced ] [ Issue History ] [ Print ]

ID

Category

Severity

Reproducibility

Date Submitted

Last Update

0001625

[XMMS2] medialib

minor

always

07-06-18 23:30

10-02-20 11:39

Reporter

wabu

View Status

public

Assigned To

Priority

normal

Resolution

open

Status

confirmed

Product Version

0.2 DrJekyll

Summary

0001625: complements of collections with unset attributes

Description

Theres a problem with collections and there complements, if it contains an attribute wich is not set on all media.

a collectin on an attribute will of course not match against media where that attribute is undefined, but the complement of the collection as well not match, which feels wrong.
strage things can happen: collectens and its complement will not equal the universe anymore ...

Additional Information

example using x2c:

>> universe.rating == 0
=> `Xmms::Collection:-609032408
    = rating:0
      [ universe ]
    0 artists:

    0 albums:

    0 titles:

>> ~(universe.rating == 0)
=> `Xmms::Collection:-609134808
    !
      = rating:0
        [ universe ]
    0 artists:

    0 albums:

    0 titles:

>>
universe
=> `Xmms::Collection:-609152998
    [ universe ]
    265 artists:
      Apocalyptica
      Ay Riders
      Björk
      ...

Tags

No tags attached.

GIT commit id

Has patch

Relationships [ Relation Graph ] [ Dependency Graph ]

related to	0001560	confirmed		Search skips tracks when using "OR"
related to	0001663	resolved	andersg	Sorting the playlist on multiple attributes isn't sorting tracks, which don't have one of the attributes
child of	0000956	resolved	theefer	Collections
child of	0001957	assigned	nesciens	Collections 2.0

Notes
(0002064) puzzles (developer) 07-06-19 00:40	IMO, the MATCH and EQUAL complement collections should return media for which the key is undefined as well as media for which the values do not match. Then, if a user wants only media for which a key is defined, but not equal, she can appropriately intersect a HAS collection.

(0002065) puzzles (developer) 07-06-19 00:48	Oh, and before my Ruby bindings for collections come into question, I've duplicated this easily using the CLI: dan@bean:~$ xmms2 mlib search NOT this_property_doesnt_exist:* -[Result]----------------------------------------------------------------------- Id \| Artist \| Album \| Title -------------------------------------------------------------[Count: ]----- dan@bean:~$ xmms2 mlib search NOT url:media -[Result]----------------------------------------------------------------------- Id \| Artist \| Album \| Title 00001\| mind.in.a.box \| Dreamweb \| mind.in.a.box-lament_snipp -------------------------------------------------------------[Count: 1]-----

Issue History
Date Modified	Username	Field	Change
07-06-18 23:30	wabu	New Issue
07-06-19 00:08	wabu	Issue Monitored: wabu
07-06-19 00:40	puzzles	Note Added: 0002064
07-06-19 00:48	puzzles	Note Added: 0002065
07-06-19 03:04	theefer	Issue Monitored: theefer
07-06-22 04:55	theefer	Relationship added	child of 0000956
07-07-12 14:43	theefer	Relationship added	related to 0001560
07-07-15 22:48	nano	Status	new => confirmed
07-08-26 02:24	puzzles	Relationship added	related to 0001663
08-03-08 15:34	nesciens	Issue Monitored: nesciens
08-05-04 18:04	nesciens	Relationship added	child of 0001957
09-02-16 23:17	nano	Target Version	=> 0.7 DrN
09-02-24 12:50	vanicat	Issue Monitored: vanicat
09-06-28 13:39	Chewi	Issue Monitored: Chewi
10-02-20 11:39	nano	Target Version	0.7 DrN => 0.8 DrO

Mantis 1.1.6[^]

Copyright © 2000 - 2008 Mantis Group